Artificial Intelligence Is Unlike Other Innovation Because It Tries To Replace Our Humanity
Joanna Maciejewska @AuthorJMac
I saw this meme posted at the top of a blog headline on Ace of spades. It's a succinct criticism of Artificial Intelligence that captures the current mood of a lot of Americans. We've never been a nation that's afraid of the future, technology or innovation. AI is different because instead of being a helper it's become a boss.
Cartoons like the Jetsons and even TV shows like Star Trek, sold us on the idea that future tech would make the labor intensive aspect of life easier. This has
mostly been the direction of innovation. Robots that did housework and computers that turned machines on an off with voice command, proved practical just decades later. Innovation keeps moving inexorably forward. How many people ride a stagecoach
across the country today? Railroads and planes made horses archaic for travel. No
one reads by candlelight anymore. The electrification of cities and homes made
it possible to work and entertain well after sundown. Not to mention the
impact on factories. Innovation makes life easier by making productivity
increase. It’s true for both labor intensive work and creative work.
Old Model New Model
In this old model innovation serves people, in the new AI
driven model, people serve innovation. Everything about the human race is
unique relative to the rest of Creation. We’re made in God’s image and we
reflect our Creator in a myriad of ways. Not all of us can write a song or
pitch a perfect game, but we carry the imprint of our Maker. That looks
different for all us. I’ve worked with people who have a gift for comfort. They
volunteer at hospitals, hospices and care centers. I use the word “gift” because
it’s a gift to the ones who are helped by it, a reflection of God's mercy. But compassion and empathy are human qualities built into us. They aren't code. They grow and develop to varying degrees in individuals.
Artificial Intelligence works through a learning/predicting formula. People are only
formulaic on the surface. You can copy much of it, but you can’t replace the
essential make up of God’s design. The apostle Paul describes it like this “For
since the creation of the world His invisible attributes are clearly seen,
being understood by the things that are made.” Romans 1:20
It’s hard to define
because no one can create life outside of nature. The best we can say about AI,
is that it does an amazing job replicating. It’s an artificial product that
functions much like the real thing. But it flattens out human irregularity and
makes efficient what was never meant to be. We’re attracted to the efficiency
of AI. But efficiency is a human invention. It’s a way of ordering our thinking
to find the quickest, cheapest and easiest way to accomplish a task.
Efficiency and Flatness
Because of efficiency we get better (smarter) at doing the
same task. Nothing is wrong with looking for easier solutions, but efficiency
is not a high moral good. It’s just the way we approach life. Modern thinking elevates it to a kind of heroic endeavor, like finding the holy grail. We never
get there but we’re moving closer every decade. In the corporate world it looks
like replacing old intranet servers with cloud based ones. Then it looks like
eliminating your IT staff, the fewer employees you have the less insurance and
payroll you’ll need to shell out. Soon you’ll need only a handful of remote
workers and eventually, none. AI will fill in the missing bits as the
accounting, marketing, IT, human resources and sales departments have been replaced by a
learning/predicting formula.
It’s the flattening of everything. Efficiency is flat.
Humans are messy and colorful and different and weird. That’s the opposite of
efficiency. None of this is to blame the companies for getting lean and trying
to compete with others. Directionally it’s wrong though and I
don’t pretend to know what to do about it. We might not need giant corporations
anymore that hire thousands of employees. But might we also have
more freedom to pursue multiple streams of income and have more agency?
Change is Inevitable
I think the AI revolution is two things; it’s one part
technology and one part money grab. Tech companies need
data centers and new laws that allow their investment to be part of the
infrastructure of the future. I won’t call it a racket (not yet at least) but I
do think a lot of the doomsday talk about 90% of jobs disappearing is designed
seed the idea that AI is going to take over. By getting us used to the notion
of this technology that decides nearly everything, we don’t protest so much.
It’s “progress” after all. Who are we to complain?
Would God allow His people to live a life as a
slave to an artificial form of intelligence like Skynet? No, but nor can I
offer an optimistic solution where technology gets back to being a helper
instead of a boss. But maybe it's doesn't have to replace creativity. Maybe it can add to instead of subtract from. A lot of people need a roadmap of the future or at least
some sense of what to put their focus on. But we’ve never had this. Go back 25
years and try to remember what you thought your future would be. Are you
working in the same field, married to the same spouse, living in the same city?
For those that are younger, do the same thing with 10 years. How much has
changed in any part of your life or the economy around you that you didn’t see
coming?
Conclusion
The point isn’t to show you how wrong you are. It’s to
recognize that change is inevitable and we can’t plan for much of it. Maybe I’m
being too optimistic and yes, ignorance is bliss to quote an unfortunate truth.
But the plan for humanity is ultimately up to God. Life gets easier when you
let Him direct your steps. It’s a scary time for those who want control, much
easier for those who trust in Jesus.
“Be anxious
for nothing but in everything by prayer and supplication, with thanksgiving,
let your requests be made known to God; and the peace of God which surpasses
all understanding will guard your hearts and mind through Christ Jesus.”
Philippians 4:6






